"Palliate or Retaliate? (Managing the cancer patient)" TUMOR TIDBITS, A BIWEEKLY EMAIL NEWSLETTER FROM GULF COAST VETERINARY ONCOLOGY Number 77; November 13, 2002. ======================================================================= THIS WEEK'S TUMOR TIDBIT: Palliate or Retaliate? ======================================================================= Everyone has a differing opinion about managing the pet with cancer. Of course all of us would love to cure cancer, but sometimes that choice is not right for the pet, or for the family. This Tidbit addresses some of the issues we consider in our practice when it comes to the choice to palliate the pet with cancer or retaliate against the cancer. THREE RULES FOR MANAGING THE CANCER PATIENT RULE 1: GET A DIAGNOSIS: Biopsy, Biopsy, Biopsy. A veterinarian can never give an accurate assessment (prognosis) or develop an appropriate treatment plan for the tumor- bearing pet without a complete diagnosis. Knowing the histologic type of tumor gives the veterinarian a sense of the natural behavior of the tumor (how it will grow, where it will go). RULE 2: EVALUATE THE ENTIRE PATIENT: Remember, there is a pet attached to the tumor. Many times we forget the BIG PICTURE. A thorough evaluation of the pet includes obtaining appropriate laboratory information (blood counts, blood chemistry, urinalysis) and survey radiographic images of the thorax, abdomen, and the tumor site. Additional information may be required depending upon the known natural behavior of the tumor (remember that biopsy you took in Rule 1 - it's extremely important). These tests may include a bone marrow aspirate, electrophoresis of serum or urine, buffy coat smears, more biopsies, ultrasound of a body area, nuclear imaging, serology, virology, or many other procedures. A thorough knowledge of the entire patient is necessary BEFORE an appropriate therapeutic plan can be presented. The goal is to identify or rule out the presence of concurrent illnesses and tumor metastases to regional lymph nodes or other body tissues (lungs, liver, skin, bone, for example). This information is essential not only for treatment planning but also to determine treatment success or failure. RULE 3: DEVELOP AN APPROPRIATE TREATMENT PLAN: Determine your goal. Is cure possible or should more emphasis be placed on quality of life (or can both be achieved)? In general, there are 3 choices facing every family with a tumor-bearing pet: CHOICE 1: WHAT IS BEST FOR THE CANCER? In today's world there are basically 2 ways to treat cancer, remove the tumor (with surgery and getting cancer-free edges all around the tumor) or destroy the tumor's ability to grow (using radiation, chemotherapy, or both; maybe in combination with surgery). There are a number of other innovative strategies under development such as immune stimulants, nutriceuticals, and tumor vessel growth inhibitors, but their true ability to control cancer is not yet known or proven (nor the best way to use them in managing cancer patients - in humans or animals). Veterinarians cure a large majority of cancers with surgery. Those that cannot be completely removed and have not yet spread to other body sites can be cured with additional measures (radiation, chemotherapy, etc) no differently than in people. Common concerns are about "how my pet look without a leg, a lower jaw, a rib?" or "how much is radiation therapy, and what are the side effects?". Every pet owner whose loved one has cancer faces these and other questions. There are no easy answers. However, if the objective of the planned treatment is to attempt a cure of the cancer, surgery with or without radiation has to be strongly considered. Talk to a Veterinary Oncologist! CHOICE 2: WHAT IS BEST FOR THE PET? Remember, for most families, quality of life for their pet is more important than the pet's remaining quantity of life. Cancer is "uncontrolled growth". If the abnormal growth cannot be removed from the body or controlled with localized radiation therapy, it is entirely appropriate to use medications (anticancer drugs, nutritional supplements, pain control medications, anti-cough or anti- nausea medications, and many others) to maximize the quality of life of the cancer-bearing pet. To "control" the "uncontrolled growth" of cancer, anticancer drugs (chemotherapy) are used. The goal of chemotherapy is to cure some cancers, but it also reasonable to use chemotherapy to slow down the growing phase of the cancer. Yes, many cancer cells are killed with chemotherapy and tumor shrinkage can be observed; however, it is impractical for most situations to expect that every cancer cell will be killed by any chemotherapy protocol or strategy. With chemotherapy, the more drugs that are used, the more often they are given, the more cancer cells that are killed. Therefore, to significantly decrease the burden of cancer and increase the lifespan of the pet, combination chemotherapy protocols that prescribe drugs every 2, 3, or 4 weeks throughout the remaining lifespan of the pet should prolong the pet's survival. Obviously, most chemotherapy drugs do not know a normal cell from a cancer cell, thus, more drugs given more often results in the possibility of more side effects. If the goal is to provide more quality of life than quantity of life, a fewer number of drugs at lesser doses given less often will still slow down cancer just not as much! CHOICE 3: WHAT IS BEST FOR THE FAMILY? It is entirely appropriate not to treat cancer in pets. In fact, in some situations, we should not recommend cancer therapy. However, just because we are not controlling the cancer does not mean we cannot provide the pet a comfortable life. When this cannot be accomplished, we should strongly urge pet owners to consider the choice of euthanasia. It is important to have a support group during this process. Please rely upon the good advice of family and friends during this difficult time. In addition, there are many pet owners who are willing to share their positive and negative experiences. It is essential to provide adequate nutritional support, pain control, and other measures that ensure the pet's good quality of life. Quality of life is very subjective. Everyone has an opinion. Ask for opinions and listen to them!!!! Then make your best choice. THERE IS NO WRONG CHOICE: Hindsight is 20:20 but if you follow the above rules - get a diagnosis and evaluate the whole patient - then you should have plenty of information to make the best choice available at that time. Always consult with a Board Certified Veterinary Oncologist. Use a team approach and allow your pet owners to participate in the team. Cancer is a battle that can be won - engage into the fight, but realize when it is time to retreat. ======================================================================= We hope this info helps and don't hesitate to call us Gulf Coast Veterinary Oncology! Kevin A. Hahn, DVM, Phd, Diplomate ACVIM (Oncology), drhahn@gcvs.com Janet K. Carreras, VMD, Diplomate ACVIM (Oncology), drcarreras@gcvs.com Glen K. King, DVM, MS, Diplomate ACVR (Radiology & Radiation Therapy), drking@gcvs.com Gulf Coast Veterinary Diagnostic Imaging & Oncology 1111 West Loop South, Suite 150, Houston, TX 77027 P: 713.693.1166 F: 713.693.1167 W: www.gcvs.com